Show: Star Trek; Deep Space Nine
Episode
Particulars: S5EP24, “Empok Nor”
Standalone
Thoughts: This is an episode that’s about atmosphere rather than story or
character. While you could argue this allows for some character development for
Garak and O’Brien, the dark corridors and ominous music make it obvious that the
writers and especially the cinematographers wanted to play with a
horror/thriller vibe this time around. And I’d say they were pretty much
successful in that. While I don’t know if I’d ever say I was creeped out, I
definitely felt tense, even though I knew it would all end relatively well.
That said, the fact that most of the away team is populated by people we’ve
never seen before does allow for more death than your average episode can get
away with. Even if they’re not wearing red shirts, the effect remains the same.
The atmosphere is doing the heavy lifting here, but I’d
say the other elements come together just fine. Garak’s descent into “evil” is
pretty good, although I feel like Robinson could have done a little more to
distinguish his normal personality from the one he displays on Empok Nor. Meany
and Eisenberg are also good, though again, I think the writers could have done
more with them. It doesn’t help that the episode blatantly foreshadowed a
cat-and-mouse game between the three of them, but only scratched the surface of
that potential. Before arriving at Empok Nor, Garak is playing a Cardassian
game called Kotra with Nog, and scolds Nog for conserving and protecting his
assets, when the point of the game is to attack boldly and decisively. He also
states that he’d like to play against O’Brien, since he thinks O’Brien has a
warrior’s instinct. I would have loved to see that mimicked in the episode,
with Nog taking a risk that worked in his favor and O’Brien proving Garak
right. Instead, all we really get is a scene later on where Garak finds another
Kotra board and blatantly states that a game of Kotra is like their current
situation. I really would have thought the writers would know better than to
blatantly spell out their metaphors, but what do I know?
Regardless, this is a fine episode, albeit one that isn’t
essential viewing. But it’s a nice break from routine, and might be an excellent
episode to watch on Halloween. Or, if you’re so inclined, you can watch it as a
warmup before watching a certain other movie that features hunting down a
killer…
How it Relates to
the Whole: While the events of this episode will never be brought up again,
Empok Nor will make a return appearance, although the sinister aspect of it
will be greatly toned down. Though given who stars in that episode, it’s kind of
to be expected…
Other: *There’s
nothing of any particular note today. We’ll see if we get more material
tomorrow.
Best
Line/Exchange: This was another episode where I made my choice fairly
early;
O’Brien: So
what did Captain Sisko do to persuade you to come along?
Garak: How do
you know I didn’t volunteer?
O’Brien (chuckles):
He threatened you, didn’t he?
Garak: Nothing so coarse. The Captain bribed me. He offered to help me procure a larger space for my workshop; the latest dressmaking equipment is surprisingly bulky.
Garak: Nothing so coarse. The Captain bribed me. He offered to help me procure a larger space for my workshop; the latest dressmaking equipment is surprisingly bulky.
O’Brien: Well,
whatever he did, I’m glad you’re here. (Garak
stares at him) What’s the matter?
Garak: Well, it’s
just that…lately I’ve noticed that everyone seems to trust me. It’s quite
unnerving, I’m still trying to get used to it. Next thing I know, people are
going to be inviting me to their homes for dinner.
O’Brien: Well,
if it makes you feel any better, I promise I will never have you over.
Garak: I
appreciate that, Chief.
I picked this partially because it’s classic Garak, but
also because I used a very similar turn of phrase in one of my stories, and I
have absolutely no doubt in my mind where it came from. Think of it as
providing credit after the fact (although the story it’s in was never officially
published, so…).
After the Fact
Update: This isn’t anything of great importance, but I remember this
blowing my mind when I first learned about it, so I figured I’d share it with
you, too (and also explain that weird comment I made at the end of Standalone
Thoughts). Thanks to someone showing me the relevant DS9 Companion entry back when I first watched the episode, I
learned to my utter astonishment that Andrew Robinson’s claim to fame before
Garak was playing Scorpio in Dirty Harry.
In fact, Robinson was kind of reluctant to do this episode, because he was
afraid it would contribute to him being typecast. Fortunately for him, they
toned down the psychopathic elements to Garak’s character in the episode, and
he felt a little better about it. And fortunately for me, it gave me a reason to rewatch Dirty Harry and appreciate it on an entirely different level. Which
is why I’m trying to give the same opportunity to you.
As you near the end of the 5th season, how would you assess the season as a whole? Besides the obvious (advancing the Dominion plot line), what would you say are the biggest characteristics of this season? Development of secondary characters (seems like Nog and Dukat have become more developed)? Sisko's growth as a commander? Darkening of the Star Trek Universe? None of these? Other things?
ReplyDeleteAnd a parlor game.... how would you rank the seasons so far? Which was best overall, which worst and why?
Excellent questions, and not always easy to answer. Let's see...
DeleteI'd say this season's biggest characteristics are developing Worf (certainly more than the show's ever developed Dax), establishing Nog as a useful member of the crew, and showing Sisko's sterner (and possibly darker) side. There's also been some development of Rom as well, though I think that started in Season 4. Plus, there was an attempt to offer some depth and/or backstory to all the main characters (Odo struggling with humanity, Quark's family, O'Brien's past as a soldier, Bashir's genetic engineering), but those were much more hit and miss. I'll talk about my impressions of the season on the whole tomorrow (it being the last episode of the season and all), but the short version is, it's fine...but I would have expected more meaty material this late in the game.
As for the season rankings...Four's probably the best blend of entertaining, character building, and plot developing, then probably Three. I think Two probably just edges out Five on the grounds of having some truly great episodes like "Necessary Evil" and "The Circle", whereas Five has been decent but with very few standouts. Leaving Season One as the worst, to probably no one's surprise. I'll be curious to see where Seasons Six and Seven fall into this mix.